The Candidate Was Never the Problem

60 minutes

Season 6

·

Episode 8

In This Conversation

Most GMs don’t wake up thinking about last night’s rate or where occupancy landed. They wake up thinking about one thing: who’s actually going to show up today?


A housekeeper quits Tuesday. The job posts Wednesday. By the time anyone calls her back, she’s down the street folding towels for somebody else.


Read Egger thinks the industry has been blaming the wrong thing. Not the labor market. Not the pay. The process.


He came up in frontline hiring — oil and gas, manufacturing, construction, then years at Traba building labor supply in new markets and personally interviewing the people nobody else was calling back. What he kept finding wasn’t a shortage of candidates. It was a master forklift operator who’d been at the same job eight years and hadn’t updated his resume because he’d never needed to, working off an Android phone, applying through a career site that wanted him to attach a document he didn’t have. It was a hiring manager who needed someone today and got back to the scheduling request nine days later, by which point the candidate was gone.


In 2024 he co-founded Achilles HR with Ben Shagel and Owen Mahoney to close that gap. Their AI recruiter, Sam, texts an applicant within minutes of them clicking apply — at 7pm, at 11pm, whenever — runs a dynamic phone screen built around the property’s own questions, scores it, and drops a vetted interview onto the hiring manager’s calendar.


Bryan takes him through the parts owners actually care about. What HR does versus what a recruiter does, and why having the first doesn’t give you the second. Who’s really running your phone screens — usually an F&B manager or a banquets manager with a 2,000-person event on the floor. Why your frontline job posting reads like you’re hiring a director of engineering when the candidate just wants to know the schedule, the pay, and what they’ll be doing. The 30 to 40% markup you’re handing a staffing agency that could have been a raise. What to do about candidates whose first language isn’t English and who’ve never been able to finish your application. And the gold mine most properties don’t know they’re sitting on — one customer couldn’t fill an AV tech role, searched their own pile of past applicants, found someone with an associate’s degree in audiovisual technology who had applied to be a housekeeper, and hired them two days later.


Then they play Two Truths and a Lie: Frontline Hiring Edition, and Read’s reasoning on the ones he gets wrong is better than most people’s reasoning on the ones they get right — including a firsthand case against earned wage access that cuts directly against the marketing.

Key Topics

Why the candidate was never the problem — the process was

65% of applicants never hear back from anyone

Where 85 to 92% of frontline applicants drop off — and why it’s your career site

In This Episode:

  • From oil and gas and construction to frontline recruiting

  • What Traba taught him about the people nobody calls back

  • The master forklift operator who never updated his resume

  • HR versus recruiting, and why having one isn’t having the other

  • Who’s actually doing your phone screens

  • How bias creeps in through a piece of paper

  • Writing a frontline job posting for an actual frontline candidate

  • Indeed’s shift to pay-to-play — and whether reposting still works

  • Craigslist, apparently, is still alive

  • The 30–40% staffing agency markup that could have been a pay raise

  • Candidates who don’t speak English, and applying by text or phone call

  • What happens when a candidate gets angry at the AI

  • Multi-property groups: shared candidate pools and not poaching your own staff

  • The AV tech who was already in their system

  • Why free ATS software that came with payroll isn’t free

  • What’s next: reference calls, sourcing, onboarding

  • Two Truths and a Lie — frontline hiring edition

  • The honest case against earned wage access

Read Egger

Chief Executive Officer

Achilles

LinkedIn Logo and Link

About Our Guest

Read Egger is the CEO and co-founder of Achilles, an AI recruiting platform built for frontline hourly hiring. Raised in Texas, he built his career in and around real industries: oil and gas, manufacturing, construction, and logistics. He then moved into recruiting technology, including several years at Traba, a frontline staffing company. Those years of calling candidates after hours and watching strong applicants slip away while managers took more than a week to respond led him to start Achilles in 2024.

Achilles’ AI recruiter, Sam, texts and calls applicants within minutes, screens them in about 50 languages, and puts scored interviews on a hiring manager’s calendar. It also searches a company’s past applicants, so hotels can hire people who already applied. Read is based in New York.